To create your free account, please enter your email address and password below. Please ensure your email is correct as you will recieve a validation email before you can login.

Email:
Nickname:
Password:
Confirm Password:
Weekly newsletter:
Daily newsletter:

To log in to your account, please enter your email address and password below:

Email:
Password:
Forgot your password?

To reset your password, please enter your email address below and we will send you a link to reset it.

Email:
Submitted by Chris Leyton on March 13 2009 - 09:18

Sonic returns exclusively on Wii as TVG asks: "where's the rest of the game"...

Pros
  • Fairly decent visuals.
  • Simple gameplay, if that's what you want.
Cons
  • Where's the rest of it?
  • Frustrating controls.
  • Simplistic beyond belief.

Following the surprisingly decent attempt at reversing the flagging hedgehog's reputation with last year's Sonic Unleashed, the blue hedgehog's latest exclusive on Wii creates a little optimism against the constant memories of Sonic's disasterous debut on PS3/Xbox 360 or the abysmal Shadow the... it's not even worth mentioning.

Switching flying carpets and genies for legendary swords and Knights of the Round Table, Sonic and the Black Knight continues Sonic Team's interest in classic folk tales following The Secret Ring by dumping the hedgehog in Arthurian legend.  It's fairly inconsequential material, even by Sonic standards, making it hard to look beyond the fact that it's little more than a reason to arm Sonic with a sword - although considering what happened the last time a hedgehog wielded a weapon... 

The similarities to Sonic and the Secret Rings are strikingly obvious.  The feeling of constant movement through the stage and resulting difficulties moving backwards are immediately noticeable, although Sonic Team has at least decided that holding the Wii Remote horizontally didn't particularly work the first time around and has decided to opt for a more conventional Nunchuk/Wii Remote setup.  It's a largely unremarkable experience from start-to-finish - which fortunately doesn't take too long.  The addition of sword fights to the Sonic format requires little more than waving the Wii Remote in an unwieldy manner and comes at the expense of key Sonic elements, namely speed, timing, and controls.  Holding up on the Nunchuk, waving the Wii Remote like a lunatic, and occasionally hitting the A button was sufficient to see us through the entire game.

Occasionally the monotony is broken by engaging in chivalrous acts towards the townspeople.  It may sound noble, but it seems little more than underhanded bribery as Sonic undertakes an unchallenging quick time event and donates 20 Rings to their humble causes - and to think, I believed Sonic 'collected' Rings!  The control/camera issues that thwarted The Secret Ring's haven't entirely been rectified despite the change to a more traditional control setup.  One section in particularly appears to have a ghostly control over Sonic and makes it nigh on impossible to head in the direction you're trying to take him. 

The blandness extends into the variety of challenges that each stage poses.  The traditional 'Go For The Goal' stage does little more than remind us just how good Sonic Unleashed was, while slightly tougher questions of your skills such as grind-runs, only using a certain number of sword thrusts, and finishing a stage while avoiding townspeople, are offset by the mundane challenge of defeating a set number of enemies or giving away a certain number of rings.  Even the boss fights against Knuckles, Shadow, and Blaze posing as Knights of the Round Table seem particularly weak as they come to a swift end with an uncoordinated barrage of Wii Remote shaking.  It's only the final showdowns against the latter bosses (we won't spoil its few surprises) that provides anything like a challenge or requires a Sonic-like sense of timing.  Even the appearance of the Knights as playable characters in the latter stages of the game (following the first end credits), fails to advance the gameplay beyond the inelegant array of Wii Remote bashing.

Sonic games have traditionally been on the short side with an underlying replay value, but sadly there's not much of this to be found in The Black Knight (perhaps it's a good thing).  The typical array of scores is rewarded upon the completion of each stage and there's a considerable horde of questionable goodies to unlock.  A die-hard Sonic fanatic could possibly point towards the bonuses awarded for Perfect Hits and chaining together attacks, and admittedly, whilst it's possible to run through the main story in a few short hours there does remain a handful of additional side challenges to return to.  But when the gameplay is as unrefined as Sonic and the Black Knight's you ultimately have to ask: what's the point? The premise of several multiplayer modes played out in a static arena only serves to extend the sense of, 'Why Sonic Team, Why?'

The King Arthur setting also appears to have given Sonic Team the canvas to be at their worst in terms of presentation.  Although the game's visuals are neat enough for a Wii title, the atrocious one-liners that proliferate throughout the entire game and 'wah-wah' wailing rock music will be enough to leave you lurching for the mute button.

If you wish to link to this article, here's a permalink to this page:

  • Graphics: 78%
     
  • Sound: 48%
     
  • Gameplay: 45%
     
  • Originality: 42%
     
  • Longevity: 20%
     
Overall Score: 4/10
Excusing the game's unbelievably short length, Sonic and the Black Knight still falls into Sonic Team's massing pit of mediocrity.  Control issues prevent any true sensation of a classic Sonic title from emerging, while any subtle depth is virtually eradicated by the overwhelming sense of simplicity.

TVG Store - Finding you the cheapest price for:

Sonic And The Black Knight

Comment

Sign Up and Post with a Profile

Join TVG for a free account, or sign in if you are already a member. You can still post anonymously.

Log in using Facebook

Respect Other Members

Please respect other users, post wisely and avoid flaming... Terms & Conditions

 

User avatar
By: Anonymous

Added:Sat 12th Nov 2011 15:45, Post No: 10

i wish it was on xbox...


User avatar
By: Anonymous

Added:Sun 07th Mar 2010 22:31, Post No: 9

is it on ps3?


User avatar
By: Anonymous

Added:Fri 18th Sep 2009 16:36, Post No: 8

shdgd


User avatar
By: Anonymous

Added:Thu 02nd Apr 2009 13:25, Post No: 7

Why downcast one of the most memorable video game characters of all time? Even though Sonic has had some less-than-perfect games, that's no reason to send him to the pits of Hades. Just wait out the storm and hope that the Sonic team has a good bout of inspiration. Besides, have you ever thought that maybe the Sonic team is doing their best to try and save the franchise? If it wasn't for their hard work, we wouldn't be talking about Sonic for as long as we do, creating all the fanart we draw, and posting comments like this one on articles that are more appropriate on a website that would have a much better time playing the games and badly criticise what some people have spent years trying to achieve


User avatar
By: Anonymous

Added:Thu 02nd Apr 2009 13:20, Post No: 6

Why downcast one of the most memorable video game characters of all time? Even though Sonic has had some less-than-perfect games, that's no reason to send him to the pits of Hades. Just wait out the storm and hope that the Sonic team has a good bout of inspiration. Besides, have you ever thought that maybe the Sonic team is doing their best to try and save the franchise? If it wasn't for their hard work, we wouldn't be talking about Sonic for as long as we do, creating all the fanart we draw, and posting comments like this one on articles that are more appropriate on a website that would have a much better time playing the games and badly criticise what some people have spent years trying to achieve


User avatar
By: Anonymous

Added:Fri 20th Mar 2009 13:46, Post No: 5

LOOOL You are definitely not serious... ¿changin percentage of graphics and re-scoring the other ones? hahahahaha, c'mon don't be mad with the hedgehog 48% sound with an orchestra and 2 big compositors behind... LOOOL


User avatar
By: Anonymous

Added:Fri 20th Mar 2009 13:45, Post No: 4

LOOOL You are definitely not serious... ¿changin percentage of graphics and re-scoring the other ones?

hahahahaha, c'mon don't be mad with the hedgehog

 

48% sound with an orchestra and 2 big compositors behind... LOOOL


User avatar
By: Anonymous

Added:Sun 15th Mar 2009 09:31, Post No: 3

48% -> GRAPHICS???

 

HAHAHAHAHA you're drunk haaahahahaaha. I can't consider you serious.


User avatar
By: Anonymous

Added:Thu 12th Mar 2009 22:58, Post No: 2

So...what about the dark queen, what's you're guys take on that boss? How do the other characters play out in the singple player adventure? How about the perfect hit mechanic? Online rankings? Forgable items? Different styles? Why do you leave out so much of this game?


User avatar
By: Anonymous

Added:Tue 22nd Jul 2008 07:03, Post No: 1

F*CK YEA. i cant wait for this. i KNOW its gonna be a great game