To create your free account, please enter your email address and password below. Please ensure your email is correct as you will recieve a validation email before you can login.

Email:
Nickname:
Password:
Confirm Password:
Weekly newsletter:
Daily newsletter:

To log in to your account, please enter your email address and password below:

Email:
Password:
Forgot your password?

To reset your password, please enter your email address below and we will send you a link to reset it.

Email:
Submitted by Chris Leyton on March 9 2009 - 11:12

Chris Redfield and Sheva Alomar team up to fight against a new threat in the return of Resident Evil...

Pros
  • Stunning visuals and presentation.
  • Sophisticated co-op gameplay.
  • Engaging boss fights.
Cons
  • Monotonous action.
  • Clunky control systems.
  • Plot fails to deliver.

Capcom's seminal horror series makes its hugely anticipated next-generation debut with the release of Resident Evil 5 on the Xbox 360 and PlayStation3.  Most famously known for Onimusha and Lost Planet, Jun Takeuchi assumes the daunting task of taking the helm on the first Resident Evil not to feature series creator, Shinji Mikami, attached to the project in some shape or form. 

Instead of taking this opportunity (along with the extra horsepower) to reinvent the series once again, Takeuchi-san has stuck close to the format established by Resident Evil 4 in 2005.  What was a survival/horror has undoubtedly continued the metamorphosis into action/horror, putting the emphasis squarely on the zombie kill count.  There's little doubt Resident Evil 5 is easily one of the most action-packed shooters around, and features the presentation and direction we've come to expect from Capcom on this generation.  Stunningly directed cut-scenes and explosive set-pieces ensure Resident Evil 5 is a veritable blockbuster that provides plenty of instant gratification, but at the same time there's an overwhelming desire for something a little bit more.

Taking control of the series' original protagonist, Chris Redfield, along with his new BSAA partner, Sheva Alomar, Resident Evil 5 depicts a new setting for the series along with a sinister new organisation to seemingly replace the ever dependable threat of Umbrella Corp.  Africa is an intriguing location to stage a series mostly known for the dark.  The sun-drenched slums of Kijuju are a fascinating sight to behold, but unfortunately it doesn't last for long and soon the sunset brings more traditional settings into play.  Although the new location is welcome it's a shame that the promised gameplay changes fail to really materialise.  Beyond a striking visual effect whenever Redfield comes out of the dark into the blinding light, we were hoping Takeuchi-san's early promises would lead to a stronger impact on the gameplay and can only imagine what such scenarios could have offered.  

Immediately the gameplay similarities to Resident Evil 4 are a little too close for comfort. Switch Los Ganados for Resident Evil 5's Majini and you're pretty close.  For reasons undeniably about ensuring balance and a sense of familiarity, Resident Evil 5's clunky interface system, tired controls, and atrocious covering system highlight a setup that feels tired compared to recent shooters.  The clunky item interface is a relic of the series and easy to look past as an attempt to retain some inkling of its past, but whereas character movement feels distinctly Resident Evil and can again be excused, the character's continued inability to shoot and move at the same time is an unforgivable legacy of its four year old predecessor. 

Balanced between the waves of Majini and various BOWs (one or two looking closer at home in Lost Planet) the occasional QTE action spices up the action and continues to wantonly demonstrate just how good RE5 looks.   Contextual actions such as ducking, close-quarter techniques, kicking down ladders, and on a solitary occasion pushing objects to form barricades, continue to bring variation to the gameplay.  Unfortunately, while Resident Evil 4's shooter gameplay still manages to keep up (just about), the decision to include a covering system seems at best ill-advised.  Little more than a desperate attempt to include the feature 'du-jour', the dire implementation feels primitive and causes plenty of frustrations with impossible camera views to wrestle with.  Takeuchi-san may have felt the need to stick close to Resident Evil 4's switch in gameplay, but hopefully there's no need for it to become Gears of War.

Although intensely slow in a classic Resident Evil manner, the plot largely fails to offer the intrigue and twists that we were hoping and fails to really go anywhere, which is particularly problematic for a series that relies on a twisting narrative to drive the experience.  Whereas Resident Evil 4 stylishly shifted the series storyline with a defining new chapter, Resident Evil 5 distinctly fails to have the same impact.  The promise of Chris Redfield's return largely surrounds the seemingly endless battle with Wesker, and while his flashbacks provide the main source of interest they fail to cause any Lost like revelations.  

We're forbidden from talking about a particular plot device, but the fact remains that the bombshell was let out of the bag along time ago and fails to have the surprise that it should.  As a result Resident Evil 5 quickly degenerates into stage after stage of killing wave after wave of increasingly obese Majini armed with better weapons.  It can all get a little monotonous and without the plot to push things forward we'd also suggest that Resident Evil 5 is never particularly scary or sufficiently builds up the tension because of the emphasis on action.  There's little denying Resident Evil 5 is an out-and-out shooter, which brings unfortunate comparisons to the likes of Gears of War.  Puzzles, previously a stalwart of the series, are virtually non-existent and leave us hoping that the series next reinvention will take this into consideration to ensure Resident Evil doesn't become just another shooter.

Resident Evil 5's sole addition is the inclusion of two-player co-op action online, system link or via splitscreen.  Marking the first appearance in the series 13 year history, Takeuchi-san and his team deserve credit for developing the concept fully.  The idea of co-op initially seems like too much of a departure from the series origins, when dogs jumping through windows made solitary players jump out of their skins.  But Resident Evil 5 undoubtedly takes co-op design at its core throughout the entire experience.  Sections that split the characters up are suitably paced, whilst there's a constant need for co-operation in everything, whether it's sharing ammo, dispatching bosses, or wolf whistling at one another. 

Consequently the game never degenerates into two players essentially playing a single-player game, there's a genuine need for each other and whilst we'd like to have seen more made of the puzzle element using this dynamic, the addition of co-op play is largely Resident Evil 5's saving grace.  The feature is further reinforced by the exceptional AI on display should you decide to play the game in single-player.  Sheva will smash crates looking for ammo, bring Majini to their knees, and generally come to your aid whenever needed, all without any prompting.  At times it's hard to believe you're not playing with another person.

Considering the sheer amount of gameplay in its predecessor, Resident Evil 5's six chapters can be completed in a surprisingly short amount of time - somewhere between 6-8 hours.  Without any major advances to the plot and a concerning dip as the game progresses, we're not entirely sure whether we'd have welcomed any more but there's a considerable sense of disappointment once the end credits roll. Worryingly co-op play makes the vast majority of situations pretty achievable, so our advice is to opt for the hardest difficulty if you're playing with a friend.  Of course the appearance of unlockables and the customary Mercenaries mode is welcome after the game's completion, the latter arguably providing more entertainment as it's able to focus entirely on the action without the need to worry about a largely non-existent plot.

If you wish to link to this article, here's a permalink to this page:

  • Graphics: 96%
     
  • Sound: 90%
     
  • Gameplay: 88%
     
  • Originality: 77%
     
  • Longevity: 76%
     
Overall Score: 8/10
The sheer emphasis on action, coupled with the dated gameplay mechanics and inability to show any advance beyond the Resident Evil 4 blueprint is possible to overlook if you're happy with state-of-the-art visuals and zombie slaying.  The addition of a fully realised co-op dynamic adds to the experience, however, making Resident Evil 5 worthwhile if you're a fan of the series, enjoy shooters or just like pretty graphics.

 

   

     

       

Comment

Sign Up and Post with a Profile

Join TVG for a free account, or sign in if you are already a member. You can still post anonymously.

Log in using Facebook

Respect Other Members

Please respect other users, post wisely and avoid flaming... Terms & Conditions

 

Pages:
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
  • 11
  • 12
  • 13
  • 14
  • 15
  • 16
  • 17
  • 18
  • 19
  • 20
  • >>
  • Next
User avatar
By: Anonymous

Added:Sat 01st Jan 2011 23:51, Post No: 536

vgcharts constantly make mistakes it switches from 4 million to 5 and least they corrected it, but in the future you really should not use vg charts as a source


User avatar
By: Anonymous

Added:Sat 01st Jan 2011 04:25, Post No: 535

stop making the same comment over and over again!


User avatar
By: Anonymous

Added:Fri 31st Dec 2010 11:38, Post No: 534

Whoever said this "this is without a doubt the lamest piece of crap i have ever seen in my entire life.....no other game has dissapointed and failed just as horribly as this one.....and to be quite honest...im still in shock....god damn piece of [#@!?]!! game companies that produce this garbage should go bankrupt NOW!!!DO NOT UNDER ANY CIRCUMPSTANCES BUY THIS GAME!!" SHUT THE [#@!?] UP (y)


User avatar
By: Anonymous

Added:Thu 17th Dec 2009 22:32, Post No: 533

My only problem with RE5 was how short it was, so I hope this expansion comes out on PC.

Also, the people who are INTERNET ANGRY about this game require too much to be happy and will probably be miserable with everything in life.


User avatar
By: Anonymous

Added:Sun 06th Dec 2009 05:31, Post No: 532

  • this is without a doubt the lamest piece of crap i have ever seen in my entire life.....no other game has dissapointed and failed just as horribly as this one.....and to be quite honest...im still in shock....god damn piece of [#@!?]!! game companies that produce this garbage should go bankrupt NOW!!!DO NOT UNDER ANY CIRCUMPSTANCES BUY THIS GAME!!

Epic Fail. That was the lamest piece of sh*t I've ever read in my entire life ! Do not any under circumstances listen to this sh*thead ! This one's going to feature a lot of puzzles, and it's confirmed that it's a survival horror.  Spoiler ***** You have to actually use puzzles to kill a certain "boss." Oh and you'll see what happens later about your weapons later. "Shanking" the enemy to death is probably impossible, but hey, I gave you a hint.

Just don't take that dumbass's word for itThis is going to be great. Try it, buy it, play it, enjoy it.


User avatar
By: Anonymous

Added:Sun 06th Dec 2009 05:24, Post No: 531

@ "this is without a doubt the lamest piece of crap i have ever seen in my entire life.....no other game has dissapointed and failed just as horribly as this one.....and to be quite honest...im still in shock....god damn piece of [#@!?]!! game companies that produce this garbage should go bankrupt NOW!!!
DO NOT UNDER ANY CIRCUMPSTANCES BUY THIS GAME!!"
For god sake, cry me a [#@!?] river. You sound like the most snobbiest brat ever.


By: SegaBoy

Added:Fri 09th Oct 2009 13:14, Post No: 530

With the emphasis on action in Resident Evil 5, clunky controls are a bit of a problem.  I'll agree they are a trademark charatceristic of the series, but if Resident Evil is headed further down a Gears of War route, then it needs to be looked at.

Personally I'd rather they kept the controls and toned down the action in place of some added significance on the puzzle count...


User avatar
By: Anonymous

Added:Fri 09th Oct 2009 01:03, Post No: 529

What a load of abject [#@!?]e, "the clunky controls can be excused" theyre supposed to be clunky genius its how the resident evil games are meant to feel.  As are the menus. I for one as a die hard fan would be seriously pissed off if the controls and menus were changed. fair point about the puzzles tho, im guessing they were removed to allow for coop play.


By: SegaBoy

Added:Thu 17th Sep 2009 22:09, Post No: 528

Care to elaborate on why?


User avatar
By: Anonymous

Added:Thu 17th Sep 2009 21:15, Post No: 527

this is without a doubt the lamest piece of crap i have ever seen in my entire life.....no other game has dissapointed and failed just as horribly as this one.....and to be quite honest...im still in shock....god damn piece of [#@!?]!! game companies that produce this garbage should go bankrupt NOW!!!
DO NOT UNDER ANY CIRCUMPSTANCES BUY THIS GAME!!


Pages:
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
  • 11
  • 12
  • 13
  • 14
  • 15
  • 16
  • 17
  • 18
  • 19
  • 20
  • >>
  • Next